Jimmy Chattin - I make better games.
Showing posts with label deeper meaning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label deeper meaning. Show all posts

Friday, December 2, 2011

7 Matt Weise - Philosophy in Games

Demon's Souls, Horror, and Holistic Design

Answers and their Points to a Set of Questions
·         Setting - very low fancy
o   Monte Python-esc portrayal of the Dark Ages
o   Only humans and monsters - very obvious
o   Very Gothic and authentically Gothic in a historical way
o   Premise put into modern day setting could not convince it was not horror
o   Silent Hill happening to an entire country
o   Describe and define what the haunting is
·         Integrated design - Demon's Souls does it best
o   Are rules different from fiction to the game? - NO!
§  e.g. Phoenix down on Aeris?
·         Shot to pieces in real life; hide and regenerate health in game
o   Coherent rules
o   Metaphysics and spiritual function is consistent in story and gameplay
o   How much power do you need?  How much are you going to take? - Corruption question
o   YOU ARE A BAD PERSON FOR BEEFING UP TO DESTROY OTHER PLAYERS
o   hitting someone with your weapon will make them very mad - > just like real life; will not hold your hand
o   the game makes you think of what a power fantasy is
§  horror is a disempowering fantasy
o   Super heroes are American
§  be stronger in an unfair fight
o   It's hard because a gamer must use common sense, not gamer sense
§  we expect a game to make us feel powerful, not us to make us feel powerful
·         Demon's Souls fiction is intermeshed into the game -> change fiction, change game
o   Humanity - "Souls are what makes humans human.  This also makes you human.  What's the difference?"
§  Dark Souls is full of philosophical questions
§  requires interpretation of the gameplay
o   The purpose of a game system is to destroy itself (game world destroying itself)
o   There is a massive collection of negative space
·         Rationalization of being a killer
o   Am I good for protecting my alliances?  Am I bad for killing innocents threatening my alliances?
o   Pay to have sins removed -> ticked NPCs love you again

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

4 Chris Pruett - What Makes Horror

Eye of Newt, Toe of Frog: Key Ingredients of Successful Horror Games

Theory: Horror games elicit emotion
·         Look at mechanics that can be used elsewhere to make emotion other than fear.
·         What makes horror games scary?

Common Traits of Scare
·         Vulnerable protagonist
o   Could be ordinary or inferior
o   Antagonists make short work of characters
o   Characters feel "real"
·         Information does not make sense
o   Clues surround imagination space
§  Clues come through narrative
o   Misinformation leads to twists in plot
o   Culture shock leads to preconceived notions of how things work that don't work
·         Level Design
o   Pattern of decent
§  Once dropping down, can't return (e.g. holes)
o   Recursion - passing through the same place, but the place changes through time
§  Recursion is not used much in Western games (more linear)
·         Cinematography / sound design
o   Control how the player sees the world
§  Cameras build tension and force shock
§  See "Fatal Frame 2"
o   Sounds build tension and leaves clues to the world
§  Sound may be more important than the visuals (see "Silent Hill" "Dead Sapce")
·         Difficulty
o   Common to all horror games
o   Running out of consumables (ammo, health, saves)

UBER TRAIT: LOSS OF CONTROL
·         A horror game is scary if it makes you feel you are not in control
·         Instill no confidence to resolve the current situation
o   Vulnerable protagonists - you can't go in and protect the character
o   Confusion - you don't feel grounded in a concrete set of rules
o   Descent - removing you from a place that is safe; narrowing of options
o   Recursion - understanding a place then having that place change removes confidence
o   Cinema - no single character is known as the protagonists until the end
§  e.g. Alien
o   Difficulty - unique to games
§  Makes or breaks a good horror games
·         The body reacts to sex and aggression identically
·         Stimulus - perception:
o   To stimulus to general autonomic arousal to particular emotion experienced to interpretation
o   To context to particular emotion experienced to interpretation
·         A hard game gives stimulus to increase personal physical state w/o context
§  Scary monsters, places, etc. can be mislabeled as fear because of difficulty

GAMES THAT FAIL
·         Dead Space
-      not a lot of descent and recursion
-      protagonist is a "bad ass"
-      difficulty is not inherent
+     sound and cinema

·         Alan Wake
-      strong protagonist (the gun)
-      not put under pressure
+     lots of negative space

·         Dream 2
-      only one spot to go to
-      no physical elevation change
-      flat journey
-      confusing story for being a confusing story
-      lack of clues forming a negative space
-      fights are not hard

·         Clocktower 3
-      character cannot easily die
-      very little difficulty
-      bosses have nothing to do with the game
-      story is nonsensical
+     vulnerable protagonist
+     plenty of recursion

·         Call of Cthulhu
-      core mechanics are broken
-      cannot select things due to camera
+     early game is hard

SUPER TERRIBLE
·         X-Files
-      squandered license
-      did not tie together aspects of copied horror games
+     fixed cameras
+     limited inventory

·         Cold Fear
-      mechanics are broken
-      ammo loss halts progress
-      saves are random and not on demand
+     structured plot

·         Obscure 2
-      characters are unbelievable
-      offensive game script
+     good art and cinema
+     innovative 2 player mode

·         The Ring
-      WHATEVER THEY DO HERE IS BAD
-      ONE OF THE WORST GAMES EVER

Play These:
·         Silent Hill Shattered Memories
·         Siren
·         Hellnight


Answers to Questions
·         Play with a friend to overcome too much fear and increase fun output when gaming.
·         Pick a game that works for you if you find it hard to play horror games.
o   e.g. don't pick zombies if you're super scared of zombies

Monday, November 28, 2011

3 Bernard Perron - A Paneled Discussion

Building the Pyramid of Scary Games: Interactive Figures and Scare Tactics in the Survival Horror Genre

Note trends; they have what is important to one’s experience and good ones travel through time.

Capturing the Experience
·         The Gaming Apparatus (a staple of our Era of Gaming)
o   contextualization
§  number of gamers
§  locale
o   hardware specs
§  platform
§  support
o   tech specs
§  resolution
§  sound
o   intervention
§  interface
·         Formal Characteristics
o   dimensionality
o   point of view
o   perspective
o   ...
·         3) Video-ludic Treatment of Horror (parameters that modulate the gamer's experience)
o   difficulty
o   “antagonization curve”
o   saving system
o   player character
§  genre
§  number of players
§  characterizations
-          inferior
-          ordinary
-          superior
-          supernatural
o   parameters setting the stage for video-ludic horror
§  general tone
-          parodic (making fun of itself)
-          horrific
-          terrifying
§  origin of fictional setting
§  horrific scenery
§  monsters
·         Categories of Fright
o   NA
·         Main Mechanisms of the Horror Game
o   NA

Intervention Mode
·         Indirect - point and click (do something not tied to actual action)
·         Symbolic direct - symbolic actions (controller; doing something like the action)
·         Mimetic direct - mimetic actions (kinetic, Wii; doing the actions)

In survival horror the player progresses alone in a strange universe; shadows shroud the presence of strange creatures.

Summary
·         Ludi Cine – a database of horror.
·         Pyramid of Horror – a stark look at how fear is instilled in the player through gameplay elements.

Sunday, November 27, 2011

2 Jeff Howard - Clive Barker


Demonik and the Ludic Legacy of Clive Barker

A Story World
Texts that are already inherently ludic (able to think clearly between bouts of insanity) make good games; gameplay concepts are implied in ludic texts.  Richly detailed imaginative worlds with internally coherent rule systems make a foundation players can relate to.  Using imaginatively productive "negative space" (gaps in a fiction) gives players incentive for exploration within the world.

Barker's Ideas
·         Rule systems and puzzle configurations can convey metaphysical ideas
o   "Making metaphysics out of hard wood"
·         Games as a metaphysically expressive medium
o   e.g. A puzzle-box opens a doorway to Hell
·         Ritualistic mysticism of play
·         Use personal injury/handicaps to express otherworldly effects better

Games:
·         have length
·         have complexity
·         have elaboration of mythology
·         are puzzles, a story, a philosophy
·         change based on the players perceptions
·         Scrying - seeing what you normally can't
o   look into one’s self and into the meanings in the environment instead of "how many guns you can muster"

Ludic Puzzles in Games
·         puzzles are with depth
·         allow players to re-configure a puzzles
·         Symbolically map the puzzles space
·         (optional) find appropriate peripheral

SUMMARY
·         A well-constructed game is a puzzle, a story, a philosophy.

Saturday, November 26, 2011

1 Steve Graham - Go and Metaphors


Life and death Problems and the Generation of Tension

GO:
·         GO is not a horror game
·         GO is ancient
·         GO is simple (2 color; simple dots)
·         GO is abstract (2 color; tiles that explicitly mean nothing)
·         GO is deterministic (not random)
·         GO is turn-based strategy
·         GO is a perfect information game (all info is known by all parties)
·         GO is a war game (surround and kill off opponent forces)

Horror:
·         It gives information in bits.
·         It is expected to be semi realistic.

GO vs Horror:
·         GO helps bring out intense emotion
o   Games such as Demon's Souls elicit emotion as well
·         Such tense emotion can drain a person
o   nothing is living, nothing is dieing, but what we attribute to the game is what affects us
o   the metaphors of the game contribute to the creation of a second world relative the the player
·         Metaphors of GO:
o   life and death
o   liberties
o   war

Creating Abstractions is Essential
                We connect dramatically simplified representations to real complexities.  Thus, abstraction creates imaginative play.

Elements of Abstraction:
·         Extended Avatar
·         Collection of pieces we have played are exposed to consequence
·         Small groups scattered about
o   body parts of our avatar
·         Patterns and objects slowly and gradually emerge
o   construction of avatar as a whole through small repeated steps
·         Risk permanent, partial death
·         Opportunity of unconditional, partial life

Metaphors and Empathy + Mechanisms
·         Life and Death problems
·         Complexity from simplicity
·         Forcing actions
·         Deadlines
·         Repeating patterns, repeated fights, and repeated threats

SUMMARY
·         Metaphors must be coherent with game play
o   players choose to associate these
·         Complex systems emerge as extended avatars
o   body parts
·         Game mechanisms - KISS
o   complexity emerging from simplicity
o   gradual and repeated construction
·         Bigger decisions with fewer resources need to be made
o   allocation of attention